Printers Ranked

Printer running costs and parts

The printer is cheap. The cartridges are not.

Find the exact cartridge, toner, drum or ink bottle your printer takes, from the manufacturer's own compatibility lists, and work out what a page really costs before you buy.

Every question on this site

13 guides

Each answer comes from the maker's or the standards body's own published documents, listed at the bottom of its page with the date we read them.

Which cartridge, toner or drum

The exact part number for the printer you own, from the manufacturer's own compatibility lists.

Running costs and choosing a printer

What a page actually costs, and which kind of printer suits how often you print.

  • Is the XL cartridge actually cheaper?

    How to turn a price and a page-yield into a real cost per page, what the ISO yield figure does and does not promise, and how to compare an inkjet against a laser or an ink tank without fooling yourself.

  • The printer that sits idle

    If you print a handful of pages a month, the failure mode is not running out of ink — it is the machine not working when you need it. What manufacturers actually document about idle behavior, and what that implies.

  • Is XL Always a Fixed Multiple? What to Buy for Each Color

    See Brother's and Epson's own declared yields for standard vs. XL cartridges and bottles, and a rule for deciding which colors are worth the upgrade.

Five things worth knowing first

Most printer advice skips the part that costs the money. Each of these comes from a manufacturer's own documentation or the ISO standard it cites.

  • The page count on a cartridge box is a test result, not a promise. Mono toner yields are declared under ISO/IEC 19752, color toner under ISO/IEC 19798 and inkjet cartridges under ISO/IEC 24711, using a fixed five-page suite (ISO/IEC 24712 — four typical customer pages plus one diagnostic page) printed continuously until the cartridge reaches end of life, in a lab held at 23.0°C ±2.0°C. Lexmark states plainly that in real use "the actual page yield will vary considerably higher or lower depending upon factors such as page coverage, job size, media type, environmental conditions, end-of-life determination, and duplex or single-sided printing."

  • The manufacturers say the same thing about their own numbers. HP's yield document states that ISO standard page yields "should be used only as a starting point for comparison purposes, and not to predict the actual yield you will get from your HP printer and cartridge." Use declared yields to compare cartridge A with cartridge B. Do not use them to budget.

  • Published yields are not always measured the same way across brands. Epson declares EcoTank replacement bottle yields "based on the ISO/IEC 24712 pattern with Epson's methodology" — that is the test pattern, not necessarily the full ISO/IEC 24711 procedure. So an Epson bottle yield and an HP or Brother cartridge yield are not strictly like-for-like, and a cost-per-page comparison across those brands carries that caveat.

  • A cartridge family number is often not enough to identify the right part. HP runs its own Printer Cartridge Lookup, which asks for your printer model, your printer's serial number and the cartridge number, and then tells you whether that machine takes newer-generation HP cartridges (warranty dates after 15 August 2019) or both older and newer generations. If the manufacturer needs your serial number to answer, a marketplace listing title cannot answer it either.

  • On a laser printer the toner cartridge is usually not the only thing you buy. Brother rates the TN760 toner at approximately 3,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752; the DR730 drum unit that holds it is rated at approximately 12,000 pages, is purchased separately, and Brother notes "Drum yield is approx., and may vary by type of use." That is roughly one drum for every four toners, and it belongs in any cost-per-page figure.

Who this is for

People choosing or resupplying a printer for a home or a one-to-ten-person office, who already know roughly what they need to print and are now facing a consumables decision: which cartridge to buy, whether the high-yield one is actually cheaper, or whether an inkjet will survive the way they actually use it. Not print-shop operators, not photographers chasing color accuracy, not IT buyers specifying managed fleets.